Return to site

Forgery and Fiscal Fraud in Judaea and Arabia on the Eve of the Bar Kochba Revolt

By Adam R. Hemmings

February 4, 2025

A Greek papyrus sheds light on legal and economic tensions in Roman Judaea and Arabia shortly before the Bar Kochba Revolt (132–136 CE). The study, authored by Anna Dolganov, Fritz Mitthof, Hannah M. Cotton, and Avner Ecker, appears in Tyche and presents a memorandum and informal minutes of a judicial hearing under a Roman official during the reign of Emperor Hadrian. The document, dating between 129 and 132 CE, captures a legal case involving accusations of forgery and fiscal fraud.

At the heart of the trial are two defendants, Gadalias and Saulos, accused of falsifying documents related to the sale and manumission of slaves. Their goal was to evade the imperial fiscus, the Roman treasury responsible for tax collection and financial administration. While the identity of the prosecutors remains uncertain, they likely belonged to the Roman fiscal administration, tasked with ensuring compliance with imperial financial regulations. Additionally, the case references an informer, highlighting the role of whistleblowers in Roman legal proceedings.

This papyrus provides valuable insight into the intersection of Roman law, local governance, and economic practices in the Near East. It reveals how provincial administrations operated, the complexities of legal disputes over slavery, and the broader socio-economic climate leading up to the Bar Kochba Revolt. The document also reflects the cultural and intellectual milieu of the time, where Roman legal traditions, Greek rhetorical practices, and Jewish social structures coexisted.

By offering the first full edition, translation, and commentary of this significant text, the authors contribute to a deeper understanding of the administrative and judicial mechanisms of Roman rule in the provinces. But, as they note, much remains to be explored about the implications of this document for our knowledge of Roman provincial governance, Jewish economic activity, and the tensions that fuelled one of the most significant uprisings against Rome.